Tag Archives: Review

Review – The First 10 Hours of Octopath Travelor

Octopath Traveler is an awkward game.  From its structure to character abilities to overworld actions, nothing seems to work as well as it should.  Still, that shouldn’t stop you from picking up this charming game that rises above its weirdness to be a solid JRPG entry for the Switch…at least at the opening.

The story of the game follows 8 separate characters as they travel the world trying to resolve their particular storylines.  Players may choose the order in which they play the 8 characters, though the game seems to encourage playing through each character’s chapter before moving on to the next.  I started as Cyrus, a noted scholar who discovers a taste for solving crimes and decides to head out into the world in search of a lost tome.  I continued on to Ophelia, a priestess on a quest for her church, and H’aanit, a huntress in search for her former master.  The order in which you select characters doesn’t appear to matter as they don’t interact and really just serve to fill out the battle party for whomever is the lead at that moment.  For what I’ve read elsewhere, this continues throughout the story.  The end result is that 8 characters will go on their life changing quests together while not acknowledging each other.  Like I said earlier, the structure is awkward, but knowing that going in meant that it really didn’t bother me.

As for the actual stories themselves, their variety is currently their biggest strength.  None of the characters is particularly compelling, but their narratives are unique enough and their stories are brief enough that none have worn out their welcome.  Thus far Octopath Traveler has also avoided repeating the standard anime clichés which plague the genre and that alone gets this game major points.  The dialogue and voice work are hit or miss with some voice actors clearly struggling with bad material (pro tip: if you don’t know Old English, don’t try to make it up).  Overall, the characters are compelling enough to provide a reason to continue on, but aren’t super strong.

The clunkiness of the dialogue is ultimately overcome by the charm of the interactions with the world.  Each character has a “path action” which lets them interact with NPCs in unique ways.  My favorite path action by far is Cyrus’ Scrutinize which gives him insight into an NPC.  This provides hidden stories, interesting side quests, town discounts, and free items all which make entering a new town feel special and fun.  The path actions are also suitably awkward, such as beating up a village elder with Provoke for…uh…reasons, but they add depth and flavor to the game.

Once the story stops and it’s time for fighting, Octopath Traveler displays a delightfully robust battle system based on weaknesses and Bravely Default’s battles.  Characters perform turn based actions which accrue them a single point each turn.  These points are exchanged for an additional action allowing players to store points and unless a massive barrage of attacks.  Meanwhile, enemies have weakness which are used to winnow down their defenses.  Once their defenses are down, the player can do serious damage.  These two systems create a tension whereby the player wants to break all of the enemies’ defenses in the same turn so they can unleash additional actions with their points.  Add in the unique fighting styles of each character and this game has a ton of playstyle variety.

On top of the excellent combat is a unique and inviting visual style.  Octopath Traveler combines 2D sprites with 3D maps reminiscent of old PSX games that were trying to make the graphics transition.  The end result is a vibrant world that beautifully conveys its many environments.  Even the standard forests and plains pop with detail and charm.  The soundtrack isn’t quite as strong, but never hampers the mood.

I’m only 10 hours in to Octopath Traveler, but I’m excited for what comes next.  This game has considerable potential and I look forward to exploring both its world and mechanics.  At 10 hours, I can’t quite say that I know enough to recommend a buy, but I can say that it’s heading in that direction.



Filed under Review, video games

Review – The First 20 Hours of Battle Chasers: Nightwar

Battle Chasers: Nightwar is a JRPG attempt at reviving an old comic book franchise that was popular early in the century.  While it probably won’t scratch the itch of Battle Chasers fans who want more content, it does competently put together a solid battle system and intriguing dungeons.  There’s fun to be had here.  For more, continue on.

The story begins with five intrepid adventurers searching for an island full of mana when their airship is attacked by bandits.  The party is divided and must explore the new land to reunite with their comrades and discover a mysterious plot hatching in this unknown land.  This could be generic launching point for a greater story, but Battle Chasers: Nightwar doesn’t seem interested in its narrative.  When it bothers to spend any time on story or characters (cutscenes are sparse), it’s largely to point the player towards the next quest.  No character, plot, or location gets much attention and the narrative feels less like a licensed property and more like a fig leaf to give the barest excuse to move on.  While I don’t know much about the Battle Chasers world, I have to imagine there is more to it than what this game shows.  Fans of the property probably won’t find their fix here.

Fortunately, the rest of the game is well constructed.  The turn-based battle system harkens back to golden age JRPGs with some interesting, though hardly mind bending, changes.  In addition to the standard special attacks and leveling up, Nightwar adds overcharge and perks.  Overcharge adds a temporary mana bar that is accrued by using basic attacks and only lasts for the duration of the battle.  Combined with the game’s tight item management and expensive spells, overcharge creates a welcome tension wherein the player must decide if waiting for overcharge is worth the time it takes to accrue.  In addition to overcharge, Nightwar includes perks.  Perks are swappable benefits which the player can use to customize characters for specific play styles.  Combined, the two systems provide enough variation to the standard JRPG format.

The real star of the battle system is how fine-tuned it is.  All but the lowest level battles require smart planning and attention to detail.  The long dungeons and restricted healing options reward smart resource management in a way that feels well balanced rather than punitive.  The only real chink in the battle system’s armor is Nightwar’s stingy economy.  The player can either find weapons or buy gear, but both take a miserly approach that can mean that a character won’t have needed equipment.  Loot drops can contain powerful items, but are too sparse to ensure that every character has what they need.  Rather than allow the player to buy missing equipment easily, Nightwar’s expensive economy ensures that the player will only have funds for an item or two rather than kitting out their party.  With a bad run of loot drops, characters won’t have the equipment they need and can be underpowered for fights.

There’s a little more to be said about Nightwar (it’s got a nice art style, for one), but the overarching message is that this is a competently executed game for gamers who like good battle systems and don’t care much about plot.  It’s possible that my abbreviated time with the game meant that I missed some amazing plot development later on, but the general tone and direction of the narrative suggests that’s not the case.  Some will view this as a worthwhile purchase at full price, but I’d say wait for a sale.

Leave a comment

Filed under Review, video games

The First Few Hours – Warhammer 40k: Inquisitor – Martyr

Warhammer 40k: Inquisitor – Martyr acts a bit like an action RPG fun house mirror.  The game is an obvious reflection of the standard Diablo formula, but does everything just a little bit differently.  The end result is a decent game in its own right, but one that will irritate an unsuspecting portion of the audience that it courts.

The game begins with the player controlled Inquisitor, a galactic enforcer of loyalty and religion, embarking a mission aboard the Martyr, a derelict Space Marine ship that went rogue and disappeared for centuries.  A quick investigation of the ship reveals that it formerly housed a long dead Space Marine leader of undetermined allegiance and is now the focus of a secret investigation by another Inquisitor who also has undetermined allegiance.  In the opening hours of the game, the player attempts to hunt down this other Inquisitor and figure out what the Martyr really is.

As far as stories go, this one is functional.  Its true virtue is to serve as a vehicle for the world of Warhammer 40k.  The player collects crew from across W40k’s Imperium of Man factions, fights its traditional Chaos foe, explores the dark realms of its cities and abandoned space stations, and generally revels in one of the better representations of this universe.  Fans of the W40k world will find much to like here and even newcomers will find Inquisitor – Martyr a relatively accessible entry point into the W40k world.  On the other hand, people who dislike the grim dark future of the 40th millennia will find nothing new or interesting.  Inquisitor – Martyr seeks to channel Warhammer 40k, not improve upon it.

The same cannot be said for the action RPG formula which the game seeks to model.  Thought clearly inspired by Diablo and its host of clones, Inquisitor – Martyr makes enough evolutionary tweaks to almost turn itself into a revolution.  The standard leveling, looting, and fighting mechanics are all there, but the emphasis is less on the former two….and arguably less on the third as well.  Leveling and looting are noticeably slower than the standard model with the player rarely experiencing substantial jumps in kill power.  Fighting is also notably slowed with the introduction of a cover mechanic which allows the player and enemies to hide in order to reap defensive bonuses.  The end result is that progress feels slow on and off the battlefield.

Perhaps the biggest gameplay innovation is the pacing.  Missions are discreet fights across small maps with specific, and occasionally varying, objectives.  Leveling, equipment swapping, and all other forms of maintenance are relegated to the pause between missions.  This creates a nice balance between character improvement and combat with each operating in its own spheres without the other spoiling its flow.  There is no standing in the middle of a blood drenched battlefield comparing shiny new swords or trying to tweak a character build.  On the flip side, the pauses between fights serve as an exhale from the game’s combat and gives the story an opportunity to breath.  While hardly used to its fullest in Inquisitor – Martyr, this model could give future ARPG’s a chance to focus on story.

Overall, the game has a solid collection of mechanics which made the first seven hours a lot of fun.  Dark clouds do loom on the horizon.  Without a compelling story and thanks to limited numbers of enemies and settings, the charms of the Warhammer 40k universe are fading against the repetitive grind of constant battles.  The slow progression ensures that the battle system won’t take up the slack.  It’s becoming harder and harder to see how Inquisitor – Martyr will earn its full price tag.  Even if you’re a big W40k fan, I’d wait for a sale.

1 Comment

Filed under Review, video games

Review – Far Cry 5 – PC

Short version:  Far Cry 5 is a good game.  It won’t change your life…or even your view on Far Cry games, but it’s polished, fun, and generally does what it set out to do.  Got it?  Good.  Let’s start reviewing this thing.

The game begins with the player running from the Eden’s Gate cult in Montana after failing to capture its leader, The Father.  The player joins up with up three sets of resistance groups trying to overthrow the three “heralds” of The Father, collectively known as the Seed family.  This is a solid enough set up for the game, but really relies on the personalities of the Seed family to carry the story beyond a basic “kill these dudes” premise.  Fortunately, the Seeds are a well-acted bunch of zealots who both convey the necessary charisma to sell their role as cult leaders and the arrogance to incentivize their downfall.  The desire to take down the cult and their leaders is enough to carry the player through the game, but the rest of the story can’t quite keep up.

For all the quality of the cast, the basic plotline is all over the map.  Developer Ubisoft clearly had larger ambitions for Far Cry 5’s story that it couldn’t quite reach.  The story has major plot elements that are haphazardly introduced and unexplained even as they take on an increasingly large role.  This all culminates in an ending that doesn’t have the support its needs resulting in it landing flat (I’ll cover this, spoilers and all, a little later).  The saving grace of it all is that the game rarely dwells on the story.  Far Cry 5 benefits from not looking or thinking too hard about it.

The gameplay is a more polished version of the standard Ubisoft fare.  All the usual staples are here including an open world map, taking over forts, doing side quests for locals, and hunting down collectibles.  Where the game shines is how it parcels these all out in interesting chunks the mean that no element ever feels overwhelming.  Even at the start, the map feels full, not cluttered.  Furthermore, the high ratio of character driven quest to mindless side mission means that I never felt obligated to do boring tasks.  I always felt I could engage with the game on the level I felt interested in at the time.

Another strong element of the gameplay was how it feeds into the look and feel of the world.  Success in missions translates to success for the resistance movements in the countryside.  Sectors that start off as overrun with cultists as civilians flee for their lives transform into battlefields and finally transition into resistance controlled space.  It’s a nice touch that makes each mission feel like a battle in a broader war and lends impact to the player’s actions.  I wish more games did this.

Even without the dynamic change in the environment, Far Cry 5 impresses with its high mountains, gentle farmlands, and lived-in buildings.  Perhaps it’s my familiarity with the setting, but I found this iteration of the series to have the most compelling, realistic world.  Seeing a place that I knew could be real and that was so well drawn pulled me in to the struggle of its residents.  This felt like a living world and an accurate reflection of the setting it wanted to portray.

In the end, Far Cry 5 isn’t a revolutionary game.  If you didn’t like its predecessors, this one won’t change your mind.  On the other hand, if you like this type of game, or were on the fence about the genre, give Far Cry 5 a shot.  It’s a polished example of the form and worth the $60.

Leave a comment

Filed under Review, video games

Review – Owlboy – PC

What the hell happened?

Owlboy had me going.  For the sweet first half of the game, I appreciated its steady learning curve, interesting puzzles, fantastic visuals, great sounds…I could go on.  This was going to be an unmitigated recommendation…and then something happened.  Owlboy made a slow steady descent into bad design choices that don’t ruin the game, but do make me wary to give it an unreserved recommendation.  Make no mistake; this is a good game.

It could have been a great one.

The interesting bit starts right from the beginning.  The player is introduced to Otus, an owl boy under the tutelage of his owl mentor Asio.  Asio is hyper critical of Otus and his strong, almost cruel, berating of the boy sets up the first of the game’s interesting characters.  Pirates attack Otus’ hometown while Otus is away forcing him to join with Geddy, a human solder, in an attempt to stop the pirates’ dastardly deeds.  The story starts incredibly strong with impactful moments that seem to have an important effect on the characters.  Otus, Geddy, and others who join later seem genuinely changed by the events.  Even side characters undergo trauma, exhibit bravery, and hint at greater development to come.  It’s all very compelling except that it never really pays off.  Most events happen as you would expect or just don’t happen at all.  At one point Geddy leaves the party due to a conflict with one of the new party members.  The other characters comment that he’ll come around and, well, he does.  The player doesn’t see his character develop which is shocking given the delicate handling of the emotional scenes in the first half of the game.  Nothing is particularly wrong with the story and characters during the second half, but they devolve into industry standard heroes rather than the complex elements they started as.

Sadly, the level design does the same.  Owlboy’s Metroidvania style action platforming stands out in the beginning as a fun, puzzle-focused romp through lush lands.  Otus can fly and use his compatriots for their abilities by picking them up.  The flight controls bleed over to the walking controls causing periodic frustration when Otus doesn’t do what the player intends, but the controls are tight enough and the levels are permissive enough that it doesn’t matter.  Owlboy also has reasonable check points, cut scene skipping, and a way to skip death animations showing considerable respect for the player’s time.  This all slowly degrades as developer D-Pad Studio sought to increase the difficulty of the game.  D-Pad introduces ever more frustrating mechanics that make the game harder, but less fun.  The mechanics devolve until the final level wherein Otus can only glide, not fly.  The confused control design between flying and platforming results in the player accidently engaging gliding when they need to get the most from their jump.  Other mechanics degrade as well such as unfortunately placed checkpoints and unskippable cutscenes in the middle of boss fights.  None of these ruin the game (after all, they are staple problems of the genre), but they seem completely unnecessary in a game that looked like it fixed them as problems.  It’s this decline in level design and mechanics that undermines the game most of all.

If anything makes up for the slow decline in quality, it would be the sound and visual design.  The songs are gorgeous and match the mood of each level.  They periodically combine with the detailed hi-bit visual design to craft a truly magical moment.  Environments get repetitive at times, but it’s always a pleasure to see the leaves rustle through the forests, watch a waterfall, or enjoy a well-positioned scene.  Unlike the other aspects of this game, the quality of the aesthetic design never fades.

It’s hard to not miss the great game that Owlboy could have been instead of the good game that it is.  The decline is noticeable and frustrating, but never wrecks the experience.  Fans of Metroidvania games should get their money’s worth and even those who general enjoy the genre should have a good time.  Owlboy doesn’t transcend the genre the way it could have, but you’ll still have a fun time playing it.

Leave a comment

Filed under Review, video games

Review – First Impressions of Civilization VI

Baby steps.

I’ve played Civilization VI for 10 hours and largely enjoyed it.  Here are my first impressions.

Unpacking cities is pretty neat

The biggest innovation of Civ VI is expanding cities beyond their single tiles.  Whereas previous games confined the city to a single spot on the map, Civ VI requires that the player place districts on nearby tiles to then build associated buildings on them.  World wonders now require specific tile combinations in addition to their technological and labor costs.  Unpacking cities succeeds in two ways.  The first is to turn district placement into a minigame where districts derive benefits from nearby districts and territory enhancements.  Skilled players can arrange a city to max out these benefits to specialize the city’s production.  The second way is how it interacts with combat.  Unpacked cities force players to defend larger swaths of territory and allow attackers to destroy meaningful aspects of a town without overrunning it.  Cities effect the landscape of combat in a way that territory improvements simply didn’t.  This makes terrain matter more too as now the player is incentivized to keep enemies outside of their territory in order to defend districts.  On the whole, unpacking cities adds new levels of welcome complexity and shakes up the formula.

Eureka moments are pretty neat too

In addition to the unpacking of cities, developer Firaxis added puzzle elements to research.  Each technological and cultural advance now has an associated quest (called a “eureka moment”) that reduces the cost of that advance.  Killing three barbarians halves the cost of Bronze Working, for example.  Players are now rewarded for pursuing a path as these quests are often tied to the playstyle that wants that particular technology.  Once again, this innovation integrates many aspects of the game by turning them into meaningful boosts for advances.  While casual players will probably never fully take advantage of the system, more devoted players will quickly develop strategies to glide through the tech paths.

Barbarians are the opposite of neat.  One might even call them not neat.

Like Civ V, Civ VI’s barbarians randomly pop up in the uncolonized places of the world and send a stream of angry relatives to go forth and murder.  Unlike Civ V, Civ VI’s barbarians took a remedial planning course and now attack in larger numbers with coordinated strikes and weaponry beyond what they player might have.  Uncolonized areas aren’t just dangerous, they are now the home of hellspawn who penalize the player for daring to live without a coastline or mountain range.  In one game, I fought barbarians in my home territory for over 30 straight turns because of three encampments placed equidistant from my capital.  Boo.  If ever there were a feature in need of a slider, barbarian spawn rates is it.  On the upside, if you can get past the angry bastards…

Expansion isn’t penalized.  Huzzah!

Civ III had corruption which turned every city after the first few into tax absorbing vampires.  Civ IV made everyone cranky once the player established too many towns.  Civ V cut off the cultural aspect of the game for daring to have an empire.  Civ VI lets you build however many cities you want.  There’s no penalty!  It’s the first time since Civ II where the player can expand without their empire collapsing.  Finally.

Leave a comment

Filed under Review, video games

Review – Ratchet and Clank – PS4

What was old, is new again.

Do you remember when the consoles were flooded with friendly cartoon characters who ran, jumped, and flew through a wide array of environments?  Do you long for collectible hunting before it became synonymous with open world, GTA style gameplay?  Insomniac has got you covered.  With the HD rerelease of Ratchet and Clank for the PS4, the glory days of mascot platforming are on display for all to see.  It’s a happy return.

The story begins with Clank, a defunct Blarg warbot who discovers plans to attack planet Novalis.  Clank escapes the Blarg only to crash land near Ratchet, a furry cat like creature with mechanical talent and dreams of saving the galaxy.  Together, they team up to defeat the Blarg and save the day.  The story is about as straightforward as I’ve presented it with only the occasional stabs of humor to set it apart from your average kid’s cartoon show.  There isn’t much here to draw in adults and the plot largely serves as a vehicle to move the player from one planet to the next.  While a game like this doesn’t need a strong story, there are moments where Ratchet and Clank’s narrative feels like a missed opportunity.  A number of characters almost use pessimistic humor before they pull away from truly amusing territory.  It happens enough times that it feels like the writers wanted to go one step further before someone stopped them.  That’s a shame, because humor would have greatly livened up the proceedings.  As it stands, the story is functional.

The gameplay is where Ratchet and Clank shines.  The game has the platformer’s usual array of jumping puzzles, but the addition of clever weaponry helps it stand out.  Ratchet has a wide array of guns which can level up through use and benefit from upgrades purchase with a special material called raretanium.  While the leveling scheme encourages the player to constantly swap weapons, the usefulness of each weapon makes the experience a delight.  Each gun has its own value, but no gun is powerful enough to work in all situations throughout the game.  The powerful sheepinator turns enemies into sheep without requiring ammo, but is ineffective against bosses.  The groovatron turns the battlefield into a dance floor, but doesn’t hurt larger enemies much.  Taking full advantage of Ratchet’s arsenal is one of the true delights of the game.  Sadly, the Clank sections are less so.  Clank relies on puzzles based on minibots whose many forms help him overcome obstacles.  The puzzles are challenging enough to keep the player interested and they break up the gameplay, but they never really satisfy like Ratchet’s shooting sections.  They are also sometimes accompanied by Clank’s hints which repeat incessantly annoying players who are enacting the solution and those who already heard the clue and wish he would just stop.

One of the joys of the Ratchet and Clank series is the vibrant, cartoony environments.  The HD remake only enhances their quality and brings the fuller vision into view.  The dynamism of the original level designs stand out with many of them taking place on an active battlefield or bustling cityscape with the attending side fights or zooming cars creating the atmosphere.  None of the environments are technical or stylistic stand outs, yet they’re so well-crafted that they’re incredibly fun to explore.  Beyond the environment, character models are sharper, colors pop, and the tiny details from the original game stand out more.  My only grip is the tiny letters, though that is likely a function of my smaller TV.  The game is a lot of fun to watch.

The rerelease adds a few features, but it’s the original game that truly draws in the player.  Developer Insomniac understood that this is a game that doesn’t need fixing and only made minor tweaks.  If you own a PS4, I highly recommend dropping some cash on Ratchet and Clank.  You’ll enjoy it.

Leave a comment

Filed under Review, video games

Review – Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc – PC

Killing high schoolers has never been so much fun!

Murder mysteries are an often neglected part of video game design space.  Whereas books, movies, and tv series have seen great success with that theme, games have generally avoided it due to the lack of obvious gameplay.  Those that have tried (Batman Arkham Asylum or L.A. Noire come to mind) have trouble making the investigatory process interesting as compared to the shooty/fighty bits of the rest of the game.  Given the challenges of the past, it’s not surprising that the game that finally gets it right is the one that commits to being a detective.  Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc succeeds because it knows exactly what kind of game it wants to be.

The story begins with Makoto Naegi attending the first day of high school at the ultra-exclusive Hope’s Peak Academy.  He walks in, falls asleep, and wakes up to find the school has been shut off from the rest of the world.   Stuck with him are his hyper talented classmates who are then informed by the sadistic murderbear Monokuma that the only way they can leave is by killing one of their classmates and getting away with it.  The rest of the story focuses on the interaction between the characters as the bodies pile up and the desperation sets in.  The set up creates a great deal of natural tension between the characters as they grapple with their desire to avoid killing (or being killed) while still wanting to escape.  Each character feels more fleshed out than your standard anime archetype and the game explores their backstories as a way to both empathize with them and establish their motivations.  The murder mystery style pushes the characters in interesting ways so much so that you’ll be sad to see them go.  In between investigations, the player can hone in on characters they particularly enjoy and these mini vignettes fill out their personalities.  Danganronpa’s character depth helps the player invest in the world and care about the outcome.

The interesting setup and strong characters would have been enough to carry the game, but the gameplay elements form a nice compliment.  Danganronpa cycles through three sections: exposition, investigation, and trial.  The first two, exposition and investigation, have the player walking around the world in a first person perspective interacting with people and objects.  There’s more than a little walking simulator DNA here, but the perspective and dingy colors establish a haunting mood.  The trial is the most interactive part.  The player plays a serious of mini games designed to piece together clues found during the investigation phase.  Most of the games get at the player’s understanding of the clues and how they fit together.  For example, one mini game has the characters speaking.  The player must select the right fact that counteracts a phrase being said.  This isn’t the deepest gameplay and one of the minigames stumbles a bit, but it neatly includes the player in the business of figuring out the mystery.  I occasionally felt confused about the answers, but they largely made sense.

…and that’s the strongest aspect of Danganronpa.  If the game indulged in the leaps of logic endemic in many other Japanese series, the mysteries and solutions would have felt unsatisfying.  Instead, developer Spike Chunsoft took the time to come up with logical solutions to its puzzles and understandable motivations for its characters.  It makes sense in the way that good murder mysteries should.  It rewards the incredible interest that its unique premise generates making the player want to continue to solve the overarching mystery of how everyone got into this mess in the first place.  The only time it falters is at the end and, even then, that’s only for a piece of the big reveal.  In all the ways that matter, Danganronpa nails it.

With Danganronpa 2 coming out on Steam (the series has primarily been Sony handhelds) in a couple of weeks, now is the ideal time to pick up the original.  My only hesitation on recommending this game is the violence.  While there is no gore, there is a great deal of blood and brutal deaths.  If you’re okay with that, the intriguing mysteries, clever characters, and unique set up will grab you until the end.

Leave a comment

Filed under video games

Review – Moon Hunters – PC

This is a thing I kickstarted.  You have been warned.

Moon Hunters is a game about stories…at least, that’s what the developers told me a couple of years ago when I saw them at PAX.  It’s about the actions of heroes and how they are immortalized through the people they help (or harm).  The game promises to let the players create their own legends except it’s missing out on one key part: the legend.  Moon Hunters feels like 3/4s of a game with the payoff missing.

The most standout feature of the game is the aesthetic.  Moon Hunters chooses a pixel based art style with fairly traditional, but varied, landscapes.  Forests are lush and green, deserts are brown and barren, and swamps have ponds showing the ripple of a falling rain drop.  Characters also animate smoothly and blend well with the environment reflecting a pleasant, unified style.  The music takes an appropriately reverential tone with plenty of otherworldly singing suited for a campfire.  On the whole, this visual and audible approach has been done before, but it’s also done well here.  The player will enjoy the little touches, even if the world doesn’t sweep them away.

Combat is similarly a step up from the norm, but not awe inspiring.  The player picks from one of four characters (local coop for up to four players) with unique skills.  They each have a main attack, an area of effect attack, and a speed move which the player uses on a top down map with a combat style akin to a twin stick shooter.  Not all the characters are sufficiently powerful (the range fighters suffer) which frustratingly extends some fights far beyond the point of fun.  Stat boosts from story vignettes scale characters well, but the opening fights can be a real slog.  Players can also purchase upgrades from merchants, though this often emphasizes the problems with the weaker characters.  Weak characters take longer to kill enemies which slows the rate of currency accumulation and thus the ability to upgrade out of peon status.  Still, the character powers are unique and combat requires tactics to perform well in.  There’s nothing special here, but enough is done right to get the requisite amount of fun.

The main selling point, the player made stories, is the weakest element.  The premise is that the player is one of several heroes of a moon worshiping village when the sun god kills the moon.  The player is then charged with reviving the moon goddess and defeating the sun god’s army.  The story after the setup is filled in with micro vignettes (they last about a minute at most) that confer or reflect traits.  These traits help establish the ending of the player’s story such as the “proud” trait inspiring other chieftains with the player’s confidence.  It’s at this point where Moon Hunters flaws are most evident.  The story wants the player to feel like they’re building a unique hero, but the procedural approach means that the trait ending stories feel disjointed.  The ending is several little blurbs of text pulled when a player has a certain trait.  It doesn’t feel cohesive or like an adequate payoff for the trouble.  Even worse, the end never shows the effect of the player’s actions making the idea of “crafting a story” feel hollow.  The player never sees the fruits of their labors, so the repeated playthroughs that the game encourages will allows fall flat at the end.

Moon Hunters is almost a solid little game executed well.  Nothing truly excels, but enough works that the game is largely an enjoyable package.  It’s a shame that developer Kitfox couldn’t stick the landing.  Buy on sale if the idea sounds interesting.

Leave a comment

Filed under video games

Review – Dragon Quest Heroes: The World Tree’s Woe and the Blight Below – PS4

“Man, I wish games stun locked me more!”

-No one, ever

Dragon Quest Heroes: The World Tree’s Woe and the Blight Below isn’t a new game.  In many ways it’s a reskin of the old Dynasty Warriors series with some Dragon Quest bits strewn about.  That doesn’t make it a bad game, but purchasers should know what they’re getting before purchasing.  You can have fun here, but only if you’re in the right mood.

The story begins in the Kingdom of Arba where man and monster live side-by-side in peace until a black fog drives the monsters mad.  This is the moment where Dragon Quest Heroes sets up on of the most unnecessary narrative contradiction I’ve ever seen and establishes a fantastically amateurish approach to storytelling in general.  The game acknowledges the obvious tension between needing to fight the rampaging monsters and knowing that they were once friends, but the gameplay didn’t seem to get the memo.  Quests in the game talk about slaughtering huge waves of monsters in retribution for them trampling a garden or making off with a pie.  Regretting monster killing doesn’t count for much if you’re going to murder them over a rose bush.  Sadly, the rest of the story is filled with these silly moments where developer W-Omega stumbles over the problems it creates.  It should then come as no surprise that characters pulled in from other Dragon Quest series aren’t supported well either.  They’re largely one note and will only satisfy their most devoted fans.  Still, there is more of a narrative than your average Dynasty Warriors game.  Given the developer’s “skills” as a storyteller, it’s a wonder that the game is coherent as it is.

The gameplay is bog standard Dynasty Warriors hack-and-slash.  Players control a party of four lead by one of two main characters.  They fight through a series of maps with effectively one of two objectives: kill all the things or protect something while killing all the things.  There isn’t much complexity anywhere, though the ability to swap characters on a whim and to invest in a skill tree for each character adds a little more interest than the usual Dynasty Warriors formula.  Mindless slashing works for most of the game, though the end stages ask for a little more strategy as they rely heavily on stun attacks which force the player to sway mindlessly for several seconds while the game plays itself.  It’s a pointless game mechanic that breaks up the monotony with frustration.  The game includes a few other features, but they’re largely designed to improve the player’s ability to smash things or give them another reason to smash things.  There really isn’t any other goal to this game.

Dragon Quest Heroes scratches the Dynasty Warriors itch.  If you’re looking for that kind of game, Dragon Quest Heroes will satisfy you as well as any of the other competent entries in the series.  Wait for a Steam sale and pick it up for 20 bucks.  Dragon Quest fans should add a little more on top of that, but not much.


Bonus Story Surprise!:  Remember how I said the story trips over itself?  There’s an even better example.  In most stories, the author tries to avoid a deus ex machina (where the author needs a totally unsupported plot element to get them out of the dead end that they’ve written themselves into).  This narrative technique is only called upon when the flaw in the story is buried deep and difficult to remove.  Dragon Quest Heroes included both the dead end and deus ex machina in the same scene.  Towards the end, the heroes flee a crumbling island.  They happen across a boss who, in his death throws, destroys the only way out.  Rather than have the gang saved by their flying cloud fortress, W-Omega has them saved by a magical bird from another dimension that is mentioned exactly zero times before that moment.  It’s so terrible that it’s beautiful.

Leave a comment

Filed under video games