Arbitrary rankings for goodness!
2014 has been a bad year for video games. From the controversy surrounding the Gamergate issue to the rash of overhyped games that failed to deliver, it’s hard to see this year as anything but a failure. Still, there have been some successes. In this article, I’ll go through my most disappointing game, but I’ll also highlight three games that show what the year could have been. Let’s hope 2015 is better.
Most Disappointing Game – Civilization: Beyond Earth
This was a crowded field. From the disappointing games I played like Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel and Farcry 4 to the others I mostly heard about like Destiny or Assassin’s Creed: Unity, 2014 was chock full of over promises and underdelivering. Even then, one game stood below the rest. Civilization: Beyond Earth. I initially met the announcement of a Firaxis developed space Civilization game with a sense of joy and excitement. We hadn’t seen a proper successor to Alpha Centauri ever and the premier turn based strategy development house was taking it on! Unfortunately, the final product proved to be an extension of Civilization’s flaws rather than a proper development of the concept. Firaxis failed to infuse the game with the story or the strategic depth of its spiritual predecessor. Even without the comparison, Civilization: Beyond Earth was just a soulless game without much to recommend it. There were certainly worse games this year, but few failed to live up to their potential like this game.
Best Surprise – Hearthstone
Blizzard Entertainment is one of the most public and successful developers, so it’s hard to say that anything they do is a real surprise. That being said, a deep, complex collectable card game is incredibly difficult to make and Blizzard had no background in it. Even without the experience, Blizzard created a fantastic experience in Hearthstone that only the beta players really saw coming. From the variety of strategies to the slick interface, Hearthstone is the digital successor to Magic: The Gathering. To be sure, the game has a ways to go. Blizzard has a great deal of design space to explore, I’m not convinced it has a grasp on how to build cards for arena, and it doesn’t seem to have a clear strategy for rolling out new cards. That being said, the base game is fantastic and accessible. We now know that Blizzard has the chops to put together a compelling card game. The question is whether it has the ability to maintain it.
Best Updates – Crusader Kings 2: Rajas of India, Charlemagne, and Way of Life
Any who have played Crusader Kings 2, know of the game’s ridiculous depth. Even the vanilla version allows a player to control thousands of Christian leaders across almost 400 years of history. Had developer Paradox walked away from their 2012 hit, it would have remained a great game. What makes it truly one of the best is Paradox’s continued commitment to updating and improving CK2. This year, we saw releases that expanded the world to India, introduced a story line around the Carolingian kings, and created an RPG-lite system for character development. Paradox made an already deep game even deeper this year and shows no signs of slowing down. If you haven’t had a chance to play this game, overcome its (admittedly, vicious) learning curve and dive into one of the best strategy titles available.
Game of the Year – Dragon Age: Inquisition
It’s telling that my best game of the year is also a heavily flawed one. DA:I suffers from a number of bugs, odd pacing issues, and a generally uninteresting cast. Even with its problems, it still provide the most compelling experience of the year. DA:I is effectively two games. It combines open world exploration with a dedicated scripted story line with the challenging, complex choices that we’ve come to expect from the Dragon Age series. More than any game of the year and most games made, DA:I provides a clear sense of the world the player is inhabiting and the people who live in it. The history, culture, and society are all center stage and intricately woven into the gameplay. It’s telling that, as much as the first Dragon Age frustrates me, DA:I has tempted me to go back, endure that frustration, and truly make the story my own.